|
Evaluation program and results at the
Neolithic Chambered Monument of
Arthur’s Stone, Herefordshire
|
Arthur’s Stone (NGR SO 3180
4313) is one of eighteen possible
Neolithic burial sites that lie
within the fertile hinterlands of
the Black Mountains of mid Wales
and the English Marches, it
is considered as the best preserved
of the group. In the recent past
the site has been extensively
researched and discussed. However,
there are a number of fundamental
questions that remain unanswered.
One of these concerns the shape of
the mound.
In July 2006 a team of
archaeologists from the Clifton
Antiquarian Club and University of
Bristol undertook an archaeological
evaluation in a field immediately
north of Arthur’s Stone and
Arthur’s Stone Lane. Prior to
these intrusive investigations,
contour and geophysical surveys
were undertaken. However, the
results of both were inconclusive.
|
The Neolithic Chambered Tomb,
Arthur's Stone (click image)
|
|
Previous interpretation suggests
that the mound is oval or circular.
Indeed, this is promoted by an
on-site display board, designed by
English Heritage, guardians of the
site. However, the morphology of
the present mound is not conducive
with other monuments within the
group. The circularity of mound
could suggest similarities with the
first phase of nearby Ty Isaf. The
first phase of this monument
comprised a circular mound with a
3m passage leading a small
rectangular gallery with
antechambers either side. It is
conceivable that both monuments
were contemporary and contact and
exchange existed between the users
of each monument. However,
successive reconnoitres by the
author suggests that the chamber
and passage were originally
incorporated into a long mound,
similar to those at Gwernvale and
Pipton Long Cairn, both also within
the Black Mountains Group.
Another unanswered research
question to face any potential
investigation is dating and
chronology. So far there are only
two sites within the Black
Mountains Group that have
calibrated radiocarbon dates. These
two sites form part of a limited
group of Welsh monuments that have
secure dating.
The monument is currently set
within an oval mound measuring
approximately 26m x 17m. The
polygonal chamber architecture
comprises nine upright stones that
support an enormous capstone,
estimated to weigh 25 tones. In
1935 the archaeologist Hemp
described the chamber as
kite-shaped, approximating the form
of the capstone. Glyn Daniel
regarded the chamber as being
laterally sited. Several meters
south of the capstone and chamber
are a large upright sandstone slab
that allegedly, has as many as
twelve large finger-dent cupmarks
on the inner face. Lying between
the chamber and the sandstone
upright is a single stone setting.
O.G.S. Crawford in 1925 suggested
this stone is actually recumbent.
It is likely that this stone, along
with the cupmarked upright, formed
part of a false portal that partly
delineated a small façade; not
surprising similar in form to other
chambered monuments within the
Black Mountains Group.
|
|
On the western side of the mound is
an unorthodox passage that leads to
the chamber. Before reaching the
chamber, the passage bends 90
degrees thus restricting the
visuality between the chamber and
the entrance area of the passage. A
number of theoretical ideas have
been put forward concerning the
relationship between the entrance,
the passage and chamber.
|
|
Prior to the evaluation that was
undertaken between July and August
2006, the precise shape of the
mound was unknown. Despite the
current shape of the mound, it
appears that it had not escaped
damage. Members of the Woolhope
Naturalists’ Field Club,
visiting the site in July 1872,
remarked that a series of stones
laid out in a circular fashion
surrounded the monument, referred
to as peristaliths. However,
there was no sign of any kerbing by
1928 when Alfred Watkins
investigated it. Indeed, based on
photographs from this period the
site had been enclosed by an iron
fence. George Nash had suggested in
2000 that the present site layout
may once been incorporated into a
trapezoidal mound. However, there
was no visible earthwork evidence
for this. As part of the morphology
of the monument, the forecourt area
(with false portal) would have been
located in the southwest; the false
portal represented by the upright
that was originally thought to be
an antechamber. From a series of
reconnoiters there was possible
evidence of a mound extending
northwards across Arthur’s
Stone Lane into adjacent fields.
Incorporated in the boundaries of
two fields that lie opposite the
site are large scatters of loose
laminated sandstone blocks that may
have originated from a cairn mound
that once extended northwards
beyond the lane and the present
site. The destruction of this part
of the monument must have occurred
prior to the early 18th century;
accounts by Nathaniel Salmon
(1728-9) suggested the present
morphology of Arthur’s Stone
has changed over the past 200
years. During Nathaniel
Salmon’s time discernible
monuments such as Arthur’s
Stone, with its folklore and local
superstition, would have suffered
destruction especially during the
16th and 17th
centuries and this may account for
the northern end of the monument
being dismantled. Based on late
19th century accounts
from Woolhope Club members, there
is also evidence that the northern
section of the mound was used as a
quarry and the stone rubble
incorporated into local
buildings.
|
|
During the 2006 evaluation
programme a total of nine trenches
were excavated. The first part of
the programme was excavated under
adverse weather conditions and
fortunately no significant
discoveries were made. However, a
series of small key-hole trenches
were excavated immediately east of
the mound. Discovered within three
of these trenches was conclusive
evidence of the primary cairn
belonging to Arthur's Stone. Finds
were, not unexpectedly meager
comprising of three flints. A
radiocarbon sample was taken from
an insecure area and the result was
disappointing. Nevertheless the
rationale of the project design was
fulfilled and we can now
categorically state that Arthur's
Stone was incorporated into a long
mound, probably trapezoidal in
shape. It is hoped that an open
excavation will take place in 2008
and reveal yet more history of this
most imposing site.
|
Trench revealing the edge of the
primary cairn (click image)
|
Back to Top
|
|
|